Write the words of this act the way you think they should read. Solon shows your change as a redline against the published text and pins it to that exact text, so it can never be applied to wording you did not see.
Change 1
As published
7 Temporary full expensing etc for expenditure on plant or machinery
(1) Part 2 of CAA 2001 (plant and machinery allowances) is amended as follows.
(2) Section 39 (first-year allowances available for certain types of qualifying expenditure only) has effect as if after the entry relating to section 45O there were inserted—
section 45S | expenditure on plant or machinery in other cases
.
(3) Chapter 4 has effect as if after section 45R there were inserted—
Expenditure on plant or machinery in other cases
45S Expenditure is first-year qualifying expenditure if—
(a) it is incurred on or after 1 April 2023 ...,
(b) it is incurred by a company within the charge to corporation tax,
(c) it is expenditure on plant or machinery which is unused and not second-hand, and
(d) it is not excluded by section 45T (exclusion of expenditure under disqualifying arrangements) or 46 (general exclusions).
Exclusion of expenditure incurred under disqualifying arrangements
45T (1) Expenditure is not first-year qualifying expenditure under section 45S if the expenditure is incurred directly or indirectly in consequence of, or otherwise in connection with, disqualifying arrangements.
(2) Arrangements are “disqualifying arrangements” for the purposes of this section if—
(a) the main purpose, or one of the main purposes, of the arrangements is to secure a tax advantage connected with expenditure being first-year qualifying expenditure under section 45S (including securing the advantage by avoiding a balancing charge under section 59A or 59B or reducing the amount or timing of such a charge), and
(b) it is reasonable, taking account of all the relevant circumstances—
(i) to conclude that the arrangements are, or include steps that are, contrived, abnormal or lacking a genuine commercial purpose, or
(ii) to regard the arrangements as circumventing the intended limits of relief under this Act or otherwise exploiting shortcomings in this Act.
(3) In this section “arrangements” include any agreement, understanding, scheme, transaction or series of transactions (whether or not legally enforceable).
(4) Section 46 (general exclusions) has effect as if—
(a) in subsection (1), after the entry relating to section 45O there were inserted—
section 45S | expenditure on plant or machinery in other cases
, and
(b) after subsection (4) there were inserted—
(4A) General exclusion 6 does not prevent expenditure being first-year qualifying expenditure under section 45S if the plant or machinery is provided for leasing under an excluded lease of background plant or machinery for a building.
(5) Section 52 (first-year allowances) has effect as if in subsection (3), in the table, at the end there were inserted—
Expenditure qualifying under section 45S (expenditure on plant or machinery in other cases) which is not special rate expenditure | 100%
Expenditure qualifying under section 45S (expenditure on plant or machinery in other cases) which is special rate expenditure | 50%
.
(6) Chapter 5 has effect as if after section 59 there were inserted—
Special balancing charge in cases of ... full expensing etc
Disposal of assets where first-year allowance made under section 45S for expenditure which is not special rate expenditure
59A (1) This section applies if a first-year allowance has been made to a company in respect of first-year qualifying expenditure under section 45S which is not special rate expenditure.
(2) If the company is required to bring a disposal value into account for an accounting period by reference to the plant or machinery on which the expenditure is incurred, the company is liable to a balancing charge for that period (whether or not it is also liable to any other balancing charge for that period).
(3) The amount of the balancing charge is the relevant proportion of the disposal value; and the relevant proportion is determined by dividing—
(a) the amount of the expenditure that was the subject of the allowance, by
(b) the total amount of expenditure that has been the subject of that or any other first-year allowance or has been allocated to a pool for that or any other accounting period.
(4) In relation to the accounting period for which the disposal value is brought into account, TDR (see section 55(1)(b)) for the pool to which the expenditure that was the subject of the allowance was allocated is to be reduced by the amount of the balancing charge.
Disposal of assets where first-year allowance made under section 45S for expenditure which is special rate expenditure
59B (1) This section applies if a first-year allowance has been made to a company in respect of first-year qualifying expenditure under section 45S which is special rate expenditure.
(2) If the company is required to bring a disposal value into account for an accounting period by reference to the plant or machinery on which the expenditure is incurred, the company is liable to a balancing charge for that period (whether or not it is also liable to any other balancing charge for that period).
(3) The amount of the balancing charge is the relevant proportion of the disposal value; and the relevant proportion is determined by—
(a) dividing the amount of the expenditure that was the subject of the allowance by two, and
(b) dividing the result of that division by the total amount of expenditure that has been the subject of that or any other first-year allowance or has been allocated to a pool for that or any other accounting period.
(4) In relation to the accounting period for which the disposal value is brought into account, TDR (see section 55(1)(b)) for the pool to which the expenditure that was the subject of the allowance was allocated is to be reduced by the amount of the balancing charge.
Sections 59A and 59B: tax avoidance arrangements
59C (1) This section applies if arrangements are entered into the main purpose, or one of the main purposes, of which is—
(a) to secure that a balancing charge under section 59A or 59B is not chargeable on a company, or
(b) to secure a reduction in the amount, or a change in the timing, of a balancing charge under section 59A or 59B which is chargeable on a company.
(2) Sections 59A and 59B are to have effect as if the arrangements had not been entered into.
(3) In this section “arrangements” include any agreement, understanding, scheme, transaction or series of transactions (whether or not legally enforceable).
Your change, as a redline
7 Temporary full expensing etc for expenditure on plant or machinery
(1) Part 2 of CAA 2001 (plant and machinery allowances) is amended as follows.
(2) Section 39 (first-year allowances available for certain types of qualifying expenditure only) has effect as if after the entry relating to section 45O there were inserted—
section 45S | expenditure on plant or machinery in other cases
.
(3) Chapter 4 has effect as if after section 45R there were inserted—
Expenditure on plant or machinery in other cases
45S Expenditure is first-year qualifying expenditure if—
(a) it is incurred on or after 1 April 2023 ...,
(b) it is incurred by a company within the charge to corporation tax,
(c) it is expenditure on plant or machinery which is unused and not second-hand, and
(d) it is not excluded by section 45T (exclusion of expenditure under disqualifying arrangements) or 46 (general exclusions).
Exclusion of expenditure incurred under disqualifying arrangements
45T (1) Expenditure is not first-year qualifying expenditure under section 45S if the expenditure is incurred directly or indirectly in consequence of, or otherwise in connection with, disqualifying arrangements.
(2) Arrangements are “disqualifying arrangements” for the purposes of this section if—
(a) the main purpose, or one of the main purposes, of the arrangements is to secure a tax advantage connected with expenditure being first-year qualifying expenditure under section 45S (including securing the advantage by avoiding a balancing charge under section 59A or 59B or reducing the amount or timing of such a charge), and
(b) it is reasonable, taking account of all the relevant circumstances—
(i) to conclude that the arrangements are, or include steps that are, contrived, abnormal or lacking a genuine commercial purpose, or
(ii) to regard the arrangements as circumventing the intended limits of relief under this Act or otherwise exploiting shortcomings in this Act.
(3) In this section “arrangements” include any agreement, understanding, scheme, transaction or series of transactions (whether or not legally enforceable).
(4) Section 46 (general exclusions) has effect as if—
(a) in subsection (1), after the entry relating to section 45O there were inserted—
section 45S | expenditure on plant or machinery in other cases
, and
(b) after subsection (4) there were inserted—
(4A) General exclusion 6 does not prevent expenditure being first-year qualifying expenditure under section 45S if the plant or machinery is provided for leasing under an excluded lease of background plant or machinery for a building.
(5) Section 52 (first-year allowances) has effect as if in subsection (3), in the table, at the end there were inserted—
Expenditure qualifying under section 45S (expenditure on plant or machinery in other cases) which is not special rate expenditure | 100%
Expenditure qualifying under section 45S (expenditure on plant or machinery in other cases) which is special rate expenditure | 50%
.
(6) Chapter 5 has effect as if after section 59 there were inserted—
Special balancing charge in cases of ... full expensing etc
Disposal of assets where first-year allowance made under section 45S for expenditure which is not special rate expenditure
59A (1) This section applies if a first-year allowance has been made to a company in respect of first-year qualifying expenditure under section 45S which is not special rate expenditure.
(2) If the company is required to bring a disposal value into account for an accounting period by reference to the plant or machinery on which the expenditure is incurred, the company is liable to a balancing charge for that period (whether or not it is also liable to any other balancing charge for that period).
(3) The amount of the balancing charge is the relevant proportion of the disposal value; and the relevant proportion is determined by dividing—
(a) the amount of the expenditure that was the subject of the allowance, by
(b) the total amount of expenditure that has been the subject of that or any other first-year allowance or has been allocated to a pool for that or any other accounting period.
(4) In relation to the accounting period for which the disposal value is brought into account, TDR (see section 55(1)(b)) for the pool to which the expenditure that was the subject of the allowance was allocated is to be reduced by the amount of the balancing charge.
Disposal of assets where first-year allowance made under section 45S for expenditure which is special rate expenditure
59B (1) This section applies if a first-year allowance has been made to a company in respect of first-year qualifying expenditure under section 45S which is special rate expenditure.
(2) If the company is required to bring a disposal value into account for an accounting period by reference to the plant or machinery on which the expenditure is incurred, the company is liable to a balancing charge for that period (whether or not it is also liable to any other balancing charge for that period).
(3) The amount of the balancing charge is the relevant proportion of the disposal value; and the relevant proportion is determined by—
(a) dividing the amount of the expenditure that was the subject of the allowance by two, and
(b) dividing the result of that division by the total amount of expenditure that has been the subject of that or any other first-year allowance or has been allocated to a pool for that or any other accounting period.
(4) In relation to the accounting period for which the disposal value is brought into account, TDR (see section 55(1)(b)) for the pool to which the expenditure that was the subject of the allowance was allocated is to be reduced by the amount of the balancing charge.
Sections 59A and 59B: tax avoidance arrangements
59C (1) This section applies if arrangements are entered into the main purpose, or one of the main purposes, of which is—
(a) to secure that a balancing charge under section 59A or 59B is not chargeable on a company, or
(b) to secure a reduction in the amount, or a change in the timing, of a balancing charge under section 59A or 59B which is chargeable on a company.
(2) Sections 59A and 59B are to have effect as if the arrangements had not been entered into.
(3) In this section “arrangements” include any agreement, understanding, scheme, transaction or series of transactions (whether or not legally enforceable).
One line that says what changes, such as "Halve the dog tax".
Who it helps, what it costs, what it fixes. It is what persuades people to support it.
A proposal here is not law. Support on Solon is evidence that people want the change; the official route says what it takes to make it law.
Sign in to file your proposal. What you have written stays on this page.
Ask what your change would do, who would gain and who would bear a cost, and where something like it is already law. The assistant reads your draft as it stands, cites the law and the studies it finds, and takes no side. What you file stays yours.