Propose a change

Capital Allowances Act 2001

Write the words of this act the way you think they should read. Solon shows your change as a redline against the published text and pins it to that exact text, so it can never be applied to wording you did not see.

Change 1

What to do with it
As published

196 Disposal values in relation to fixtures: general

(1) The disposal value to be brought into account in relation to a fixture depends on the nature of the disposal event, as shown in the Table— Table Disposal values: fixtures 1. Disposal event | 2. Disposal value 1. Cessation of ownership of the fixture under section 188 because of a sale of the qualifying interest except where item 2 applies. | The part of the sale price that— falls to be treated for the purposes of this Part as expenditure incurred by the purchaser on the provision of the fixture, or would fall to be so treated if the purchaser were entitled to an allowance. 2. Cessation of ownership of the fixture under section 188 because of a sale of the qualifying interest where— the sale is at less than market value, and the condition in subsection (2) is met by the purchaser. | The part of the price that would be treated for the purposes of this Part as expenditure by the purchaser on the provision of the fixture if— the qualifying interest were sold at market value, that sale took place immediately before the event which causes the former owner to be treated as ceasing to be the owner of the fixture, and that event were disregarded in determining that market value. 3. Cessation of ownership of the fixture under section 188 where— neither item 1 nor 2 applies, but the qualifying interest continues in existence after that time or would so continue but for its becoming merged in another interest. | The disposal value given for item 2. 4. Cessation of ownership of the fixture under section 188 because of the expiry of the qualifying interest. | If the person receives a capital sum, by way of compensation or otherwise, by reference to the fixture, the amount of the capital sum. In any other case, nil. 5. Cessation of ownership of the fixture under section 190 because the lessee has become the owner under section 183. | The part of the capital sum given by the lessee for the lease referred to in section 183 that falls to be treated for the purposes of this Part as the lessee’s expenditure on the provision of the fixture. 6. Cessation of ownership of the fixture under section 191 (severance). | The market value of the fixture at the time of the severance. 7. Cessation of ownership of the fixture because section 192(2)(a) (assignment of rights) applies. | The consideration given by the assignee for the assignment. 8. Cessation of ownership of the fixture because section 192(2)(b) (discharge of equipment lessee’s obligations) applies on the payment of a capital sum. | The capital sum paid to discharge the financial obligations of the equipment lessee. 8A. Cessation of ownership of the fixture because section 192A(2)(a)(assignment of rights) applies. | The consideration given by the assignee for the assignment. 8B. Cessation of ownership of the fixture because section 192A(2)(b) (discharge of client’s obligations) applies on the payment of a capital sum. | The capital sum paid to discharge the financial obligations of the client. 9. Permanent discontinuance of the qualifying activity followed by the sale of the qualifying interest. | The part of the sale price that— falls to be treated as expenditure incurred by the purchaser on the provision of the fixture, or would fall to be so treated if the purchaser were entitled to an allowance. 10. Permanent discontinuance of the qualifying activity followed by the demolition or destruction of the fixture. | The net amount received for the remains of the fixture, together with— any insurance money received in respect of the demolition or destruction, and any other compensation of any description so received, so far as it consists of capital sums. 11. Permanent discontinuance of the qualifying activity followed by the permanent loss of the fixture otherwise than as a result of its demolition or destruction. | Any insurance money received in respect of the loss and, so far as it consists of capital sums, any other compensation of any description so received. 12. The fixture begins to be used wholly or partly for purposes other than those of the qualifying activity. | The part of the price that would fall to be treated for the purposes of this Part as expenditure incurred by the purchaser on the provision of the fixture if the qualifying interest were sold at market value. (2) The condition referred to in item 2 of the Table is met by the purchaser if— (a) the purchaser’s expenditure on the provision of the fixture cannot be qualifying expenditure under this Part or Part 6 (research and development allowances), or (b) the purchaser is a dual resident investing company which is connected with the former owner. (3) Items 1 and 5 of the Table are subject to sections 198 and 199 (election to fix apportionment on sale of qualifying interest or grant of lease). (4) Section 192(3) (assignee of equipment lessee) applies in relation to item 8 of the Table. (4A) Section 192A(3)(assignee of client) applies in relation to item 8B of the Table. (5) Nothing in sections 188 to 192A or this section prevents a disposal value having to be brought into account under Chapter 5 because of a disposal event not dealt with in these sections. (6) This section is subject to section 197.

Your change, as a redline

196 Disposal values in relation to fixtures: general

(1) The disposal value to be brought into account in relation to a fixture depends on the nature of the disposal event, as shown in the Table— Table Disposal values: fixtures 1. Disposal event | 2. Disposal value 1. Cessation of ownership of the fixture under section 188 because of a sale of the qualifying interest except where item 2 applies. | The part of the sale price that— falls to be treated for the purposes of this Part as expenditure incurred by the purchaser on the provision of the fixture, or would fall to be so treated if the purchaser were entitled to an allowance. 2. Cessation of ownership of the fixture under section 188 because of a sale of the qualifying interest where— the sale is at less than market value, and the condition in subsection (2) is met by the purchaser. | The part of the price that would be treated for the purposes of this Part as expenditure by the purchaser on the provision of the fixture if— the qualifying interest were sold at market value, that sale took place immediately before the event which causes the former owner to be treated as ceasing to be the owner of the fixture, and that event were disregarded in determining that market value. 3. Cessation of ownership of the fixture under section 188 where— neither item 1 nor 2 applies, but the qualifying interest continues in existence after that time or would so continue but for its becoming merged in another interest. | The disposal value given for item 2. 4. Cessation of ownership of the fixture under section 188 because of the expiry of the qualifying interest. | If the person receives a capital sum, by way of compensation or otherwise, by reference to the fixture, the amount of the capital sum. In any other case, nil. 5. Cessation of ownership of the fixture under section 190 because the lessee has become the owner under section 183. | The part of the capital sum given by the lessee for the lease referred to in section 183 that falls to be treated for the purposes of this Part as the lessee’s expenditure on the provision of the fixture. 6. Cessation of ownership of the fixture under section 191 (severance). | The market value of the fixture at the time of the severance. 7. Cessation of ownership of the fixture because section 192(2)(a) (assignment of rights) applies. | The consideration given by the assignee for the assignment. 8. Cessation of ownership of the fixture because section 192(2)(b) (discharge of equipment lessee’s obligations) applies on the payment of a capital sum. | The capital sum paid to discharge the financial obligations of the equipment lessee. 8A. Cessation of ownership of the fixture because section 192A(2)(a)(assignment of rights) applies. | The consideration given by the assignee for the assignment. 8B. Cessation of ownership of the fixture because section 192A(2)(b) (discharge of client’s obligations) applies on the payment of a capital sum. | The capital sum paid to discharge the financial obligations of the client. 9. Permanent discontinuance of the qualifying activity followed by the sale of the qualifying interest. | The part of the sale price that— falls to be treated as expenditure incurred by the purchaser on the provision of the fixture, or would fall to be so treated if the purchaser were entitled to an allowance. 10. Permanent discontinuance of the qualifying activity followed by the demolition or destruction of the fixture. | The net amount received for the remains of the fixture, together with— any insurance money received in respect of the demolition or destruction, and any other compensation of any description so received, so far as it consists of capital sums. 11. Permanent discontinuance of the qualifying activity followed by the permanent loss of the fixture otherwise than as a result of its demolition or destruction. | Any insurance money received in respect of the loss and, so far as it consists of capital sums, any other compensation of any description so received. 12. The fixture begins to be used wholly or partly for purposes other than those of the qualifying activity. | The part of the price that would fall to be treated for the purposes of this Part as expenditure incurred by the purchaser on the provision of the fixture if the qualifying interest were sold at market value. (2) The condition referred to in item 2 of the Table is met by the purchaser if— (a) the purchaser’s expenditure on the provision of the fixture cannot be qualifying expenditure under this Part or Part 6 (research and development allowances), or (b) the purchaser is a dual resident investing company which is connected with the former owner. (3) Items 1 and 5 of the Table are subject to sections 198 and 199 (election to fix apportionment on sale of qualifying interest or grant of lease). (4) Section 192(3) (assignee of equipment lessee) applies in relation to item 8 of the Table. (4A) Section 192A(3)(assignee of client) applies in relation to item 8B of the Table. (5) Nothing in sections 188 to 192A or this section prevents a disposal value having to be brought into account under Chapter 5 because of a disposal event not dealt with in these sections. (6) This section is subject to section 197.

One line that says what changes, such as "Halve the dog tax".

Who it helps, what it costs, what it fixes. It is what persuades people to support it.

A proposal here is not law. Support on Solon is evidence that people want the change; the official route says what it takes to make it law.

Sign in to file your proposal. What you have written stays on this page.

Sign in to file it

Think it through

Ask what your change would do, who would gain and who would bear a cost, and where something like it is already law. The assistant reads your draft as it stands, cites the law and the studies it finds, and takes no side. What you file stays yours.

Questions to start with
Think it through
Legal information from the published text, not advice for your case. Check the sources. Find a law · What the register holds