Propose a change

Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992

Write the words of this act the way you think they should read. Solon shows your change as a redline against the published text and pins it to that exact text, so it can never be applied to wording you did not see.

Change 1

What to do with it
As published

154 New assets which are depreciating assets.

(1) Sections 152, 153 and 229 shall have effect subject to the provisions of this section in which— (a) the “held-over gain” means the amount by which, under those sections, and apart from the provisions of this section, any chargeable gain on one asset (“asset No.1”) is reduced, with a corresponding reduction of the expenditure allowable in respect of another asset (“asset No.2”), and (b) any reference to a gain of any amount being carried forward to any asset is a reference to a reduction of that amount in a chargeable gain coupled with a reduction of the same amount in expenditure allowable in respect of that asset. (2) If asset No.2 is a depreciating asset, the held-over gain shall not be carried forward, but the claimant shall be treated as if so much of the chargeable gain on asset No.1 as is equal to the held-over gain did not accrue until— (a) the claimant disposes of asset No.2, or (b) he ceases to use asset No.2 for the purposes of a trade carried on by him, or (c) the expiration of a period of 10 years beginning with the acquisition of asset No.2, whichever event comes first. (2A) If asset No 2 or shares in a company which holds asset No 2 are transferred as part of the process of a merger to which section 140E applies, the transfer shall be disregarded for the purpose of subsection (2), and for that purpose— (a) if the transferee holds asset No 2, it shall be treated for the purpose of subsection (2), in relation to asset No 2, as if it were the claimant, or (b) if the transferee holds shares in the company which holds asset No 2, section 175 shall apply in relation to the group of which the transferee is a member as if it were the same group as any group of which the claimant was a member before the merger. (2B) If, as part of the process of a merger to which section 140E applies, the transferee becomes a member (whether or not as the principal company) of a group of which the claimant is also a member, for the purposes of subsection (2) section 175 shall apply in relation to the trade carried on by the claimant as if the group of which the transferee is a member were the same group as the group of which the claimant was a member before the merger. (2C) In subsections (2A) and (2B), “transferor” and “transferee” have the meaning given by section 140E(9). (2D) Subsections (2A) and (2B) shall apply in relation to the transfer of an asset in circumstances where section 140A applies as they apply in relation to the transfer of an asset on a merger to which section 140E applies, and for that purpose— (a) references to the merger shall be treated as references to the transfer, (b) references to section 140E shall be treated as references to section 140A, and (c) references to the transferor and the transferee shall be treated as references to the transferor and the transferee in relation to the asset. (3) Where section 229 has effect subject to the provisions of this section, subsection (2)(b) above shall have effect as if it read— (b) section 232(3) applies as regards asset No.2 (whether or not by virtue of section 232(5)), or . (4) If, in the circumstances specified in subsection (5) below, the claimant acquires an asset (“asset No.3”) which is not a depreciating asset, and claims under section 152 or 153— (a) the gain held-over from asset No.1 shall be carried forward to asset No.3, and (b) the claim which applies to asset No.2 shall be treated as withdrawn (so that subsection (2) above does not apply). (5) The circumstances are that asset No.3 is acquired not later than the time when the chargeable gain postponed under subsection (2) above would accrue and, assuming— (a) that the consideration for asset No.1 was applied in acquiring asset No.3, and (b) that the time between the disposal of asset No.1 and the acquisition of asset No.3 was within the time limited by section 152(3), the whole amount of the postponed gain could be carried forward from asset No.1 to asset No.3; and the claim under subsection (4) above shall be accepted as if those assumptions were true. (6) If part only of the postponed gain could be carried forward from asset No.1 to asset No.3, and the claimant so requires, that and the other part of the postponed gain shall be treated as derived from 2 separate assets, so that, on that claim— (a) subsection (4) above applies to the first-mentioned part, and (b) the other part remains subject to subsection (2) above. (7) For the purposes of this section, an asset is a depreciating asset at any time if— (a) at that time it is a wasting asset, as defined in section 44, or (b) within the period of 10 years beginning at that time it will become a wasting asset (so defined).

Your change, as a redline

154 New assets which are depreciating assets.

(1) Sections 152, 153 and 229 shall have effect subject to the provisions of this section in which— (a) the “held-over gain” means the amount by which, under those sections, and apart from the provisions of this section, any chargeable gain on one asset (“asset No.1”) is reduced, with a corresponding reduction of the expenditure allowable in respect of another asset (“asset No.2”), and (b) any reference to a gain of any amount being carried forward to any asset is a reference to a reduction of that amount in a chargeable gain coupled with a reduction of the same amount in expenditure allowable in respect of that asset. (2) If asset No.2 is a depreciating asset, the held-over gain shall not be carried forward, but the claimant shall be treated as if so much of the chargeable gain on asset No.1 as is equal to the held-over gain did not accrue until— (a) the claimant disposes of asset No.2, or (b) he ceases to use asset No.2 for the purposes of a trade carried on by him, or (c) the expiration of a period of 10 years beginning with the acquisition of asset No.2, whichever event comes first. (2A) If asset No 2 or shares in a company which holds asset No 2 are transferred as part of the process of a merger to which section 140E applies, the transfer shall be disregarded for the purpose of subsection (2), and for that purpose— (a) if the transferee holds asset No 2, it shall be treated for the purpose of subsection (2), in relation to asset No 2, as if it were the claimant, or (b) if the transferee holds shares in the company which holds asset No 2, section 175 shall apply in relation to the group of which the transferee is a member as if it were the same group as any group of which the claimant was a member before the merger. (2B) If, as part of the process of a merger to which section 140E applies, the transferee becomes a member (whether or not as the principal company) of a group of which the claimant is also a member, for the purposes of subsection (2) section 175 shall apply in relation to the trade carried on by the claimant as if the group of which the transferee is a member were the same group as the group of which the claimant was a member before the merger. (2C) In subsections (2A) and (2B), “transferor” and “transferee” have the meaning given by section 140E(9). (2D) Subsections (2A) and (2B) shall apply in relation to the transfer of an asset in circumstances where section 140A applies as they apply in relation to the transfer of an asset on a merger to which section 140E applies, and for that purpose— (a) references to the merger shall be treated as references to the transfer, (b) references to section 140E shall be treated as references to section 140A, and (c) references to the transferor and the transferee shall be treated as references to the transferor and the transferee in relation to the asset. (3) Where section 229 has effect subject to the provisions of this section, subsection (2)(b) above shall have effect as if it read— (b) section 232(3) applies as regards asset No.2 (whether or not by virtue of section 232(5)), or . (4) If, in the circumstances specified in subsection (5) below, the claimant acquires an asset (“asset No.3”) which is not a depreciating asset, and claims under section 152 or 153— (a) the gain held-over from asset No.1 shall be carried forward to asset No.3, and (b) the claim which applies to asset No.2 shall be treated as withdrawn (so that subsection (2) above does not apply). (5) The circumstances are that asset No.3 is acquired not later than the time when the chargeable gain postponed under subsection (2) above would accrue and, assuming— (a) that the consideration for asset No.1 was applied in acquiring asset No.3, and (b) that the time between the disposal of asset No.1 and the acquisition of asset No.3 was within the time limited by section 152(3), the whole amount of the postponed gain could be carried forward from asset No.1 to asset No.3; and the claim under subsection (4) above shall be accepted as if those assumptions were true. (6) If part only of the postponed gain could be carried forward from asset No.1 to asset No.3, and the claimant so requires, that and the other part of the postponed gain shall be treated as derived from 2 separate assets, so that, on that claim— (a) subsection (4) above applies to the first-mentioned part, and (b) the other part remains subject to subsection (2) above. (7) For the purposes of this section, an asset is a depreciating asset at any time if— (a) at that time it is a wasting asset, as defined in section 44, or (b) within the period of 10 years beginning at that time it will become a wasting asset (so defined).

One line that says what changes, such as "Halve the dog tax".

Who it helps, what it costs, what it fixes. It is what persuades people to support it.

A proposal here is not law. Support on Solon is evidence that people want the change; the official route says what it takes to make it law.

Sign in to file your proposal. What you have written stays on this page.

Sign in to file it

Think it through

Ask what your change would do, who would gain and who would bear a cost, and where something like it is already law. The assistant reads your draft as it stands, cites the law and the studies it finds, and takes no side. What you file stays yours.

Questions to start with
Think it through
Legal information from the published text, not advice for your case. Check the sources. Find a law · What the register holds